Worries over stigma are driving a push to rename monkeypox, but the process is

On Sep 15, 2022

Public health experts have worried that stigma could steer people away from getting tested and vaccinated. A new name can help slow the spread of the disease, they say, but it needs to come quickly.

But that was months ago.

Typically, the scientist who isolates a virus gets to suggest a name. The naming of the species is the responsibility of WHO’s International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses.

Scientists have been calling this virus “monkeypox” for 64 years.

In 1958, researcher Preben von Magnus and his team in Copenhagen, Denmark, discovered two outbreaks of a “pox-like disease” in a colony of crab-eating macaque monkeys that their lab used for polio vaccine production and research.

Opinion: The two ways to fight monkeypox and end the stigma around it

The first human case of monkeypox wasn’t documented until 1970. Scientists discovered a case in a 9-month-old boy in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The child recovered from the monkeypox infection but died six days later from measles. After that, cases of the painful disease were documented in West and Central Africa.

Cases in other places were almost all linked to travel, according to the CDC. But in 2018, the agency noted that over the previous decade, more human cases had been reported in countries that had not seen the disease in several decades. This emergence, it said, was a “global health security concern.”

The global push for the name change started this year, when an outbreak took off in countries where monkeypox was not commonly found.

New names for old viruses

The naming process had already been underway to reconsider the names of all orthopoxvirus species, WHO said in an email to CNN, including cowpox, horsepox, camelpox, raccoonpox and skunkpox, as well as monkeypox.

According to WHO taxonomy committee member Colin McInnes, the panel has a mandate to bring “virus species nomenclature into line with the way that most other forms of life are named.”

Black and Hispanic people are more likely to get monkeypox but less likely to be vaccinated

Traditionally, poxviruses were named after the animal in which the disease was first spotted, but that created some inconsistencies, he said.

Monkeypox probably didn’t start in monkeys. Its origin is still unknown. The virus can be found in several other kinds of animals like Gambian giant rats, dormice and a couple of species of squirrels.

McInnes, who is deputy director and principal scientist with the Moredun Group, which develops vaccines and tests for livestock and other animals, studies squirrelpox — which also may be in line for a name change. He has been looking into the feasibility of producing a vaccine against the virus, which can be fatal for red squirrels in the UK.

The current species known as “monkeypox virus” and the others would then be renamed to “orthopoxvirus ‘something,’ ” he said in an email to CNN.

“It is the ‘something’ that is currently being debated,” McInnes wrote.

He said some scientists would prefer that the monkeypox name be kept in order to retain the link to 50 years of published research. Others would like a totally different name.

The WHO committee has until June 2023 to suggest changes.

In August, WHO announced that a group of experts had come up with new names for the clades, or variants, of monkeypox. Prior to more modern conventions about names, scientists would name a variant for the region where it emerged and was circulating.

Now, to remove any stigma that comes with naming a disease for a region or country, the Congo Basin clade will be called clade I. The former West African clade is clade II. A subvariant, clade IIb, is what is primarily in circulation in the current outbreak.

Dangerous stigma

Many scientists say WHO needs to work with more urgency.

In July, after weeks had gone by no action, the New York City health commissioner sent a letter to WHO, urging it to “act in this moment before it is too late.” It cited “growing concern for the potentially devastating and stigmatizing effects that the messaging around the ‘monkeypox’ virus can have on these already vulnerable communities.”

School is in session. Should you worry about your kid catching monkeypox?

Since the outbreak has largely affected gay and bisexual men and other men who have sex with men, stigma has been an ongoing concern for WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus.

“Stigma and discrimination can be as dangerous as any virus,” Tedros said when he declared monkeypox a global health emergency in July.

In the US, the virus is disproportionately affecting Black and Hispanic people, according to the CDC. Local public health data also shows that fewer members of either community are getting the monkeypox vaccine.

Experts are concerned that in addition to the barriers that make access to any kind of health care difficult, some people may not get the vaccine or get tested because of the stigma associated with the disease.

Dozens of suggestions

In the WHO 2015 naming conventions, the organization encouraged those who name diseases to avoid places, names, occupations and animals due to stigmatization.

In August, WHO encouraged people who want to propose new names for monkeypox to submit suggestions to its website. More than 180…

Worries over stigma are driving a push to rename monkeypox, but the process is

New names for old viruses

Dangerous stigma

Dozens of suggestions

Get more stuff like this in your inbox

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox